Issue No. 35, December 2011

I will name you the degrees. The first, the Retort Courteous;
the second, the Quip Modest;
the third, the Reply Churlish;
the fourth, the Reproof Valiant;
the fifth, the Countercheck Quarrelsome;
the sixth, the Lie with Circumstance;
the seventh, the Lie Direct.

~ William Shakespeare


Comeback ... or Setback?

Ah, the crafty comeback. Who among us has never yearned for the obsidian arrowhead of words in the face of the rude, tiresome or just plain senseless question or remark from strangers, or from relatives whose blood is not thicker than water. MAD magazine’s Al Jaffee raised the art of the comeback to its highest humorous form in his series of Snappy Answers to Stupid Questions books. Among my favorites, a mother with identical, dressed-alike five-year-old sons, fields the same question over and over: “Are they twins?” “No,” deadpans the mother. “He’s an only child. Who’s your eye doctor?” And in a true story, an American couple who adopted Korean twins decided to have some fun with the many strangers who asked “Are they adopted?” Dad responded with “No, this is what happens when you do it sideways.”

These humorous comebacks apply a light touch to obvious or silly questions, but they achieve what we all want of a pithy retort—that we get the last word, that those words have enough bite to puncture and deflate the party who has offended us. For some of us, the compulsion to do this skyrockets when the remarks and questions come as insults to our children or our parenting competence. Though autism awareness among the general population has grown in recent years, ignorance still abounds, and we are all astounded by how judgmental and mean-spirited some folks can be in that ignorance.

Our children with autism navigate the world through an obstacle course unimaginable to those who have no familiarity with autism. The sensory challenges alone would bring down most healthy adults, not to mention the layering on of communication frustrations, disruptions of routine and environment—and having to deal with unreasonable people.  “Why can’t you get your kid to ______?” “Will he ever be normal?” Sooner or later most of us raising a child with autism will face the rude question, the derisive glare, the just-loud-enough-to-overhear put-down. And the yearning for a snappy comeback ignites.

With the  last decade’s increase in autism comes an increase in families confronting the unkindness of strangers, and an accompanying glut of advice on formulating comebacks. Societal incivility in general is spreading like fungus, so it’s no surprise that the snappy comeback has veered away the humorous or thoughtful edge that might actually lead to a shared chuckle, a conversation and a degree of understanding of autism. Websites touting “best” autism comebacks offer the likes of:

“You should teach your son table manners.”
“Totally! I couldn’t stop him from flicking a booger into that salad you just finished.”

“All he needs is a good smack and he’ll get the message.”
“If I holler at you in French, will you become fluent?”

“Can’t you stop her from doing that?”
“She only does it when her autism is in its contagious stage.”

I’m uneasy with the proliferation of this type of comeback, as I am with anything that drives a deeper wedge between our kids and the vast general population with whom they must learn to interact if they are to take their rightful place in the world as productive, independent adults. I want to erase, not darken, the line drawn by the us-them mentality, and any mentality that views the child with autism as a lesser being.

The snarky comeback lowers us to the level of our harasser. The satisfaction it may give us is momentary. It’s done nothing to enlighten an uneducated mind. It models for our child a means of sustaining, intensifying and elevating conflict rather than resolving it. It propagates and mirrors the incivility we so deplore when it is directed at our children. If each of us in our own small sphere won’t make the choice to refuse being part of it, how will this ship of crassness ever turn around? Is it easy to keep a civil tongue in your head while those around you cannot or will not, when they harpoon you in your most tender spot? Hell no. Not much about parenting a child with autism is easy. But taking the high road in the face of jerks and meddlers becomes the easier choice when we consider that our responses to ignorance and prejudice shape our child’s future, one encounter at a time. It’s really a very simple choice: perpetuate the status quo, or build awareness, understanding and acceptance, one mind at a time.

Refusing to lower ourselves to the level of our tormenters doesn’t amount to retreat or meekness. We often rue words flung in anger but seldom regret taking the high road. That I so deeply believe this didn’t mean it was always easy for me to model it for my children. I’m petty enough to be proud of the time I gave a mouthy rhymes-with-witch the three-finger salute and told her to read between the lines. But it was worth the hundreds of snarling retorts I swallowed or pre-empted to see how my sons have grown into young men who stand up for themselves assertively, civilly, often with humor, and often stepping in to defend those who struggle as they did (and do).

Consider too that silence can be an eloquent comeback. Not every remark or stare is worthy of your response. I truly did not care (still don’t) about the opinions of strangers in public, people I didn’t know and would never see again, people who had no understanding—and in many cases, no desire to understand—the factors leading up to the moment in time where our paths intersected. The famous journalist H. L. Mencken employed a single response to all critics and hecklers: “Dear Sir or Madam: You may be right.”

As I write this, Bryce is finishing an essay for a college writing class, laying out the elements of what he considers an ideal education. The teaching of self-advocacy and respectful interpersonal communication skills, he argues, is as important as any academic subject. Our advocacy for our child with autism educates others. In setting the tone of that discourse, especially in front of our children, we sow the seeds of their own brand of self-advocacy. Corrosive or constructive? We mustn’t allow comebacks to become setbacks. If there were to be an all-purpose retort, perhaps it’s that “We’re all still learning.”

Further reading: Rx for Battle Fatigue

© 2011 Ellen Notbohm


Current Reads

Autism Asperger’s Digest – Perspective: Rethink, Reframe, Relate

Our George Washington Moments

 A recent study by Twentieth Century Fox Home Entertainment claims that adults tell an average of three lies per day. Most often, this study concluded, we lie to our partners, but we also lie to our coworkers and our friends. We lie about tasks done or not done, about what we’ve eaten, what we spend, where we’re going, where we’ve been, who we’ve been with today or long ago. What this study appears not to have explored is how often we lie to our children. . .

Children’s Voice – Exceptional Children: Navigating Special Education and Learning Differences

When I Grow Up I Want to Be . . .

Rare is the parent who has never wondered what his or her child will grow up to be. Rare I am not, although I did postpone my wondering until my children were into puberty. I might have postponed the wondering about my son Bryce, who has autism, longer but for a middle school teacher who volunteered the opinion that she could “see our friend Bryce doing well in a cubicle doing clearly delineated tasks exactly as he is told.” There’s nothing wrong with cubicle jobs, but Bryce was already interested in filmmaking, an outside-the-cubicle profession if ever there was one . . .

MetroKids Philadelphia

Let’s Make a Deal

Contracts and deals can be effective behavior management tools in the home and in the classroom environment. When used effectively, deals and contracts can reduce behavioral problems, keep attention focused and teach one of life’s critical lessons: work = reward. However, pitfalls abound in setting up contracts and deals, especially with children who lack important social skills that contribute to a shared understanding of the contract’s parameters. . .


Read me on your iPad!
My books are now available for download on iTunes.

Did you miss my November newsletter?
In All-inclusive: how parents and teachers can encourage sports participation in children with autism, learn how impairments in autism can affect ability to participate in PE or group sports, and how teachers, coaches and parents can modify their instruction in a manner that allows the child with autism to participate successfully and safely. You can read it here.

Meet me in person
I am now booking speaking engagements, readings and book signings for 2012. Contact me at emailme@ellennotbohm.com

Join the discussion and keep up with my latest on Facebook
This is where you’ll find the latest news, dialogue and preaching ;o) about all the subjects my work encompasses. Post your comments and share your ideas. This month our topics included whether autism/Asperger’s is an excuse for bad manners, preparing or kids for standardized testing—or not, how the Occupy movement relates to autismSee you on Facebook!

Visit me at www.ellennotbohm.com
Book excerpts, articles, news blog, foreign translations, newsletter archive. Stop by and tell me what you think and what you’d like to see.

Follow me on Twitter at EllenNotbohm

Invite me to visit you
Got blog? Yes, I do guest shots. Got book group? We can hook up by phone or Skype. Got show? Web, radio and podcast interviews available via phone or Skype.


Book excerpts on website

Cick here for book excerpts

Ten Things Every Child with Autism Wishes You Knew
from Chapter 8: Please Help Me with Social Interactions

Ten Things Your Student with Autism Wishes You Knew
In its entirety, Chapter 3: I Think Differently

1001 Great Ideas for Teaching and Raising Children with Autism or Asperger’s, 2nd edition
"What We Miss in Misbehavior” and "Game Plan for Meltdowns"

The Autism Trail Guide: Postcards from the Road Less Traveled
“The Power of a Cookie”


Newsletter archive: if you are new to our newsletter community, please visit the newsletter archive on my website and browse some popular past features at my newsletter archive


If you’ve read my books and feel inclined to share your thoughts with others, please consider posting a review on my book pages at www.amazon.com. It’s easy to do and you don’t have to post your real name.


Please forward this newsletter to anyone you feel might share an interest in our kids with autism. New subscribers can sign up at here.


©2011 Ellen Notbohm | Third Variation Strategies